Product Management is Considered Evil

(I have been sitting on this post, because it is mostly a rant. I actually try to not be negative and sarcastic. Plus this is not about Multicore in any way. Anyhow, it needs sayin’.)

If you are working in a modern company, you have probably encountered “Product Management”. If you have not encountered this modern corporate management marvel, count yourself lucky. I have worked with Product management for 8 years as an engineer and a manager. The honest to God truth is, this emperor has no clothes.

First, some history

The idea of Product Management came from a Harvard Business Review article. The original idea is from the late 80’s. I can not find the link right now.

In any business there are different groups all pulling for the greater common good of the company. Groups like marketing, sales, production (operations) and engineering all come from different worlds, so see the world differently. These different world views cause conflict and friction. We are all trying our best, but attack the problem of business from different sides, and so friction is the result.

Obviously, all this conflict is not good. It hurts the product, especially if one group dominates the others. Sales wants a cheap product with every possible feature, so no customer can toss them out because the product does not do XYZ. Marketing wants something flashy and cool to build campaigns and Super Bowl ads. Production wants consistency, nothing new, just churn out the existing widget. Engineer will create a solution in search of a problem, very cool, if you are a geek and can figure out the menus. So, a battle rages, with a good balance the company produces good products, but that is really hard.

Into the middle of this comes the Product Manager.  From Wikipedia:

product manager investigates, selects, develops, products for an organisation, performing the activity of product management.

A product manager considers numerous factors such as intended demographic, the products offered by the competition, and how well the product fits in with the company’s business model. Generally, a product manager manages one or more tangible products. However, the term may be used to describe a person who manages intangible products, such as music, information, and services.

This person stands in the middle, the hub of the organization. They take in the wishes of sales, the marketing input, understanding of the technology and the competition and produce the idea product that fits the market. Success is assured.

Sounds good, don’t it.

The original idea came from a marketing professor, so this role of great power is a marketing role. That does not really matter, but usually the Product Managers are in the organization chart under Director of Marketing or similar.

Product Management’s Problem

Steve Blank pointed out “Why Product Managers Wear Sneakers“. The idea he presents is the Product Management does not work for a startup the same way it would work for an established company. I argue Product Management does not work. Now you have to ask why I feel it fails.

First, as I described above, the Product Manager is the hub, the man in the middle, making high stakes decisions for the future of the company. That is for your future and mine as fast growing, hugely profitable companies don’t usually do lay offs. You can just see the Product Managers standing on a rocky outcrop, staring into the morning sun, their cape flowing in the breeze.

Unfortunately the people I have known who do this job do not wear capes, and have no super powers. They were all very nice people, and I count some of them as close personal friends. What I am trying to say is the job as described takes a super human organizer and negotiator. So, I have yet to find a truely effective Product Manager in the past eight years of my career.

It is the nature of the position, not the people. The product of a Product Manager is the Marketing Requirements Document, or MRD. Writing requirements is a thankless task. They are never complete, there is never time do get them all right, consistent and testable. Plus, there is no help. With all the new agile methods, requirements are seen as something from the bad old days of waterfall development. Of course when the engineers get hold of the MRD, we rip through it and point out every flaw. It is in our nature, as right brained thinkers. A thankless task indeed.

They must negotiate the fine line of asking for features and solutions, but not dictating the implementation. That is a requirements problem, not just Product Management. They are the ones who must stay on the fine line, making the job harder.

Next is the schedule. Schedule is huge for hitting the market first, training the sales team, and having the big splashy role out and Super Bowl ads. The poor Product Manager does not get to set the development and test schedule. If your engineering management lets them set the schedule, I am sorry to say that you are really in deep shit. We have heard this tune before, they need it next quarter for the 83 Million dollar customer, it will take six months to develop, and then we have to test it, do a beta, and integrate with third party systems.

The poor Product Manager often falls into the role of the Project Manager. They are not the same and should not be. Project Managers manage the project and the schedule. Unfortunately the Product Manager’s future depends on getting the projects done. They have the vested interest, so wind up managing the schedule. The big problem is that there interest is not always in line with the project. As the project evolves into product, the Product Manager wants it done sooner, cheaper. Quality can suffer.

A good friend of mine moved from an engineer job to a product manager job. He told me the biggest headache was being the monkey in the middle. There was little he could do to force other groups to do his bidding. He was in marketing, they were engineering or manufacturing. All he could do was ask, negotiate, and hope. He is a good guy,  who can negotiate and is not shy. Still it was impossible to make his goals the goals of the other groups.

Product Management Never Innovates

The final nail in the Product Management coffin is that they do not innovate. What does that even mean, innovate?

Sales, marketing and product management tend to evolve products. They want to take the existing product and add a clock.

“You should have just taken an existing product and put aclock on it or something.”

– Homer Simpson

True, no one of us is Steve Jobs and even he did not come up with the iPhone on his own. The idea that pivots your company is not coming from product management or marketing. Once again Steve Blank talks about innovation in a large company. (You should be subscribe to his blog!)

Product Management is trying to make a business case for something new. A huge, incredibly difficult task. Why not take the existing business model and extend it, look at competition, and do something where there are data points to make the ROI easier to figure? It works, the business keeps expanding. Features get added to the checklist. All is well.

All is well until the company gets blind sided. A competitor does a leap frog, or a scrappy startup takes the whole business onto the web.

By the time the path is obvious, it is too late.

How can you help?

If you have a friend who is a product manager, or you are thinking about moving into marketing (it is tempting), is there help? Can Product Management be saved?


Still, you can help. First of all, when you talk to a product manager, ask them if they or your company is a member of the Pragmatic Marketing group. They are the industry group and offer training and seminars. It is no IEEE, but it is all they have.

Second, read the books on requirements. Found here and here. Help get a good MRD. Think of it as enlightened self interest.

Finally, be a friend and help them when you can.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s